Similar articles

Abstract: The high-speed train makes strict demands on the long-term performance of the track-subgrade. The key scientific point of research on the performance of high-speed railway subgrade is the mechanical and hydraulic properties of the subgrade under the coupling of dynamic cycles, dry-wet cycles, and temperature cycles. Much further research work should be done for the maintenance of existing high-speed railways and the new construction of high-speed railways.

高铁路基近期研究

随着高速铁路的快速发展，高铁路基的研究成为一大热点。目前大量的研究工作集中在高铁路基动力响应、工后沉降和长期服役性能。这些工作促进了对高铁路基一般规律的了解，但距准确评价路基在百年服役过程中经受干湿循环、温度变化与动荷载耦合作用下服役性能的改变尚远。本文总结了高铁路基近期的研究成果，并提出了未来的研究方向。
高铁路基；动力响应；工后沉降；长期服役性能

1.  Background

 In recent years, the rapid development of high-speed railways in China has surprised the world with the so-called “China speed”. The total mileage of high-speed railway will reach 1.6×10⁴ km by 2020. As a result, “High-speed Railway Diplomacy” has become a national strategy. In the world, many countries are making their high-speed railway plans. The safety and comfort of high-speed trains raises the strict demands on the performance of the track-subgrade system during the service life over 100 years, for example, strict post-construction settlement at millimeter level, appropriate dynamic stiffness, and long-term durability. Under extreme climatic conditions such as heavy rainfall, persistent drought, and extreme low or high temperatures, long-term dynamic loading on the track-subgrade will cause many engineering problems, including excessive settlement, mud pumping, cracks in the slab, large voids under the slab, erosion of the reinforced concrete structure. Those engineering problems have been found in many operational high-speed railways. The research into the problems is still insufficient.

2.  Dynamic response of track-subgrade

 The research on the dynamic response of train-track-subgrade has made many achievements. Zhai et al. (2009; 2013a; 2013b) has established a robust 35-degree-of-freedom vehicle-track coupled dynamics model. Dynamic responses of the carriages can be analyzed by this model in the case of carriages passing over curved tracks. Much research on the dynamic response of the subgrade has been conducted using analytical methods (Metrikine, 2004), 3D dynamic finite element method (Hall, 2003), 2.5D finite element method (Bian et al., 2008), field monitoring (Mishra et al., 2012; Verbraken et al., 2012; Cui et al., 2014), and model tests (Chen et al., 2013; 2014a; 2014b). Those studies have shown that the track-subgrade vibration is significantly associated with the train speed. There exists a critical train speed close to the Rayleigh wave velocity of the track-subgrade (Bian et al., 2008). When the train speed is slower than the critical speed the vibration level increases almost linearly with the train speed. When the train speed equals the critical speed, the resonance of the track-subgrade causes a great increase in the vibration level. In practice, due to the high quality of fill material used in the subgrade construction, the critical speed is always higher than the train speed. Hence, the resonance can hardly be observed through field monitoring and model tests.

 The dynamic stress on the subgrade surface is an important design load which is used to design the subgrade and the soil improvement measures. There are many factors that influence the dynamic stress on the subgrade, including carriage type, train speed, track type, and environmental factors. From field measurement, it can be found that the dynamic stress on the subgrade surface ranges from 15–20 kPa for ballastless track, and 50–100 kPa for ballast track. In the Chinese Code for Design of High Speed Railway TB 10621 (MRC, 2009), the dynamic load magnification factor (DLF) for the subgrade is 3.0 for a train speed of 300 km/h, and 2.5 for a train speed of 250 km/h. In the German Railway Standard Rail 836 (2008), for a train speed of 300 km/h, the DLF of the slab is 1.7 to 2.1, and 1.24 to 1.5 for the subgrade. The influence of environmental factors, such as the unevenness of the rail caused by the settlement of the subgrade, the degradation of the subgrade stiffness on the dynamic stress needs further study. In-situ measurement or full-scale model tests can be used to study the distribution of dynamic stress in the subgrade.

 It is regarded that the influence depth of the dynamic stress on the performance of the subgrade is only 3 m for ballastless track. Beneath 3 m the dynamic stress is so small that it can be neglected. The distribution of the dynamic stress in the subgrade with the depth can be derived from Boussinesq’s solution, though the shape of the subgrade and the ground soil is not an exact elastic half-space. Most of the research on the dynamic stress was conducted without the consideration of soil improvement piles. In China, the soft or loose soils under the embankment will be improved with piles. The method for calculating the dynamic stress in the subgrade with Boussinesq’s solution should be further verified for a piled embankment. It is found from a full-scale model test for a low embankment improved with piles that the soil arching (Fig. 1) changes the distribution of dynamic stress in the subgrade (Chen et al., 2014c): the dynamic stress above the pile caps is enhanced greatly; on the contrary, the dynamic stress above the soil between the caps decreases greatly (Fig. 2). The large number of cycles of dynamic loading on the pile cap will cause the accumulative settlement of the pile. It is found that when (SLR+CLR)<0.5 (SLR: static loading ratio; CLR: cyclic loading ratio), there is no accumulative settlement of the pile in silt soils (Chen et al., 2011). The study on the accumulative settlement of the pile under a large number of cycles of dynamic loading should be made in future studies.







 Future research will focus on the ground and structure vibration due to the train passing, and protection methods will be studied for vibration sensitive structures. Studies on certain kinds of railway sections, such as the inhomogeneous soil profile in longitudinal and lateral directions, and transition sections, should be proposed.

3.  Post-construction settlement of the track-subgrade

 The post-construction settlement of the track consists of the consolidation settlement of foundation soils, accumulative settlement of the subgrade under train loading, and the accumulative settlement of foundation soils (or piles) under train loading. Generally, the post-construction settlement of the subgrade and foundation under static load belongs to a traditional soil mechanics problem. The post-construction settlement of piled embankments for highways are rarely considered due to the limited total settlement of soil improved with piles. But the post-construction settlement of a piled embankment for high-speed railways becomes important due to the strict demands of the settlement. Zhou et al. (2012) developed a semi-solution for solving the consolidation of a piled embankment in soft ground. Puppala and Chittoori (2012) evaluated the effectiveness of deep soil mixing (DSM) columns for stabilizing soils in arresting the distress posed to the pavements. Accumulative settlement of the subgrade under train loadings is a hot research topic. The commonly used research methods are a full-scale triaxial test (Suiker et al., 2005; Ishikawa et al., 2011; Mishra et al., 2013), full-scale model tests (Chen et al., 2014a; 2014b; 2014c), and discrete element method (Huang and Chrismer, 2013). It shows that these are three types of the plastic strain development model: plastic shakedown, plastic creep, and incremental collapse (Werkmeister et al., 2005). The development model of plastic strain depends on the ratio between the dynamic stress and initial confining pressure. The greater the ratio is, the more likely the soil will fail. Experimental studies have taken the stress level, number of cycles, particle size distribution, and degree of compaction into consideration.

 Although some approaches have been developed to calculate the accumulative settlement, the accuracy of those approaches is low. This is mainly due to the very small accumulative settlement and the uncertainties of the soil parameters. Hence, it is better to propose some threshold values related to the dynamic soil stress to control the development of the accumulative settlement. Further studies should focus on the influence factors on the threshold values, such as saturation, compaction coefficient, gradation, etc. Discrete element method (DEM) and computer tomography (CT) are two useful measures to study the behavior of the subgrade. With the use of pile supported low embankment in soft soil area, pile settlement in the dynamic and static load combinations has become an important part of subgrade settlement. Currently research in this area is not sufficient, high-speed rail design specification shave no clear rules and calculation methods.

4.  Long-term serviceability of subgrade

 During the service life of high-speed railways, the track-subgrade will suffer drying-wetting cycles, dynamic stress cycles and temperature cycles. For example, the variation of temperature in north China will be 60 °C. Nurmikolu (2012) thought it was crucial to understand and take into account the frost action mechanism in cold climate, especially where seasonal frost occurs. The water content in the subgrade will also change greatly from the optimum water content during the construction to the saturation status during the wet season. The change of the water content in the subgrade has a significant impact on the subgrade settlement (Fig. 3, Chen et al., 2014a). Future research tendencies will concentrate on the following aspects: (1) the soil-water characteristic curve and permeability of coarse grained subgrades; (2) the water movement in the subgrade under heavy rainfall. Then, the engineering parameters of the high-speed railway subgrade will be proposed, and advice about fine particles content, grading, and structural design will also be given.

5.  Summary

 The high-speed train makes strict demands on the long-term performance of the track-subgrade. The key scientific point of research on the performance of high-speed railway subgrade is the mechanical and hydraulic properties of the subgrade under the coupling of dynamic cycles, dry-wet cycles, and temperature cycles. Much further research work should be done for the maintenance of existing high-speed railways and the new construction of high-speed railways.

.  Introducing editorial board member:

---

* Project supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Nos. 51225804, U1234204, 51178418, and 51222803), and the Research Fund by China Railway Corporation (No. 2014G006)