Full Text:   <6453>

CLC number: TB3

On-line Access: 

Received: 2009-07-27

Revision Accepted: 2009-07-31

Crosschecked: 2009-08-07

Cited: 19

Clicked: 4602

Citations:  Bibtex RefMan EndNote GB/T7714

-   Go to

Article info.
1. Reference List
Open peer comments

Journal of Zhejiang University SCIENCE A 2009 Vol.10 No.11 P.1541~1560


J-integral resistance curve testing and evaluation

Author(s):  Xian-kui ZHU

Affiliation(s):  Battelle Memorial Institute, Columbus, Ohio 43221, USA

Corresponding email(s):   zhux@battelle.org

Key Words:  J-integral, J-R curve, Fracture toughness, Fracture testing, Crack growth

Share this article to: More |Next Article >>>

Xian-kui ZHU. J-integral resistance curve testing and evaluation[J]. Journal of Zhejiang University Science A, 2009, 10(11): 1541~1560.

@article{title="J-integral resistance curve testing and evaluation",
author="Xian-kui ZHU",
journal="Journal of Zhejiang University Science A",
publisher="Zhejiang University Press & Springer",

%0 Journal Article
%T J-integral resistance curve testing and evaluation
%A Xian-kui ZHU
%J Journal of Zhejiang University SCIENCE A
%V 10
%N 11
%P 1541~1560
%@ 1673-565X
%D 2009
%I Zhejiang University Press & Springer
%DOI 10.1631/jzus.A0930004

T1 - J-integral resistance curve testing and evaluation
A1 - Xian-kui ZHU
J0 - Journal of Zhejiang University Science A
VL - 10
IS - 11
SP - 1541
EP - 1560
%@ 1673-565X
Y1 - 2009
PB - Zhejiang University Press & Springer
ER -
DOI - 10.1631/jzus.A0930004

In this paper a critical review is presented of the history and current state of the art of J-integral resistance curve testing and experimental evaluation methods in conjunction with a discussion of the development of the plane strain fracture toughness test standard ASTM E1820 developed by American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM). Early research efforts on this topic are reviewed first. These include the J-integral concept, experimental estimates of the J-integral for stationary cracks, load line displacement (LLD) and crack mouth opening displacement (CMOD) based η factor equations, different formulations of J-integral incremental equations for growing cracks, crack growth corrected J-R curve determination, and experimental test methods. Recent developments in J-R curve testing and evaluation are then described, with emphasis on accurate J-integral incremental equations, a normalization method, a modified basic method, a CMOD direct method with use of incremental equations, relationships of plastic geometry factors, constraint-dependent J-R curve testing and correction approaches. An overview of the present fracture toughness test standard ASTM E1820-08a is then presented. The review shows that after more than 40 years of investigation and development, the J-integral resistance curve test methods in ASTM E1820 have become simpler, more cost-effective and more accurate.

Darkslateblue:Affiliate; Royal Blue:Author; Turquoise:Article


[1] Anderson, T.L., 1995. Fracture Mechanics: Fundamentals and Applications (2nd Ed.). CRC Press, USA.

[2] ASTM E1820-08a, 2008. Standard Test Method for Measurement of Fracture Toughness. American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) International, West Conshohocken, PA, USA.

[3] Bakker, A., 1985. A DC Potential Drop Procedure for Crack Initiation and R-Curve Measurements during Ductile Fracture Tests. Elastic-Plastic Fracture Test Methods: The User’s Experience, ASTM STP 586, p.394-410.

[4] Begley, J.A., Landes, J.D., 1972. The J-Integral as a Fracture Criterion. Fracture Mechanics, ASTM STP 515, p.1-23.

[5] Chao, Y.J., Zhu, X.K., 1998. J-A2 characterization of crack-tip fields: extent of J-A2 dominance and size requirements. International Journal of Fracture, 89(3):285-307.

[6] Chao, Y.J., Zhu, X.K., 2000. Constraint-modified J-R curves and its applications to ductile crack growth. International Journal of Fracture, 106(2):135-160.

[7] Chao, Y.J., Zhu, X.K., Kim, Y., Lam, P.S., Pechersky, M.J., Morgan, M.J., 2004. Characterization of crack-tip field and constraint for bending specimens under large-scale yielding. International Journal of Fracture, 127(3):283-302.

[8] Clarke, G.A., Landes, J.D., 1979. Evaluation of the J-integral for the compact specimen. Journal of Testing and Evaluation, 7(5):264-269.

[9] Clarke, G.A., Andrews, W.R., Paris, P.C., Schmidt, D.W., 1976. Single Specimen Tests for JIC Determination. Mechanics of Crack Growth, ASTM STP 590, p.27-42.

[10] Cotterell, B., 2002. The past, present and future of fracture mechanics. Engineering Fracture Mechanics, 69(5):533-553.

[11] Cravero, S., Ruggieri, C., 2007. Further developments in J evaluation procedure for growing cracks based on LLD and CMOD data. International Journal of Fracture, 148(4):387-400.

[12] Donato, G.H.B., Ruggieri, C., 2006. Estimation Procedure for J and CTOD Fracture Parameters Using Three-Point Bend Specimens. Proceedings of the 6th International Pipeline Conference, Calgary, Canada.

[13] Džugan, J., Viehrig, H.W., 2004. Application of the normalization method for the determination of J-R curves. Materials Science and Engineering A, 387-389:307-311.

[14] Ernst, H.A., Paris, P.C., Landes, J.D., 1981. Estimations on J-Integral and Tearing Modulus T from a Single Specimen Test Record. The 13th Conference on Fracture Mechanics, ASTM STP 743, p.476-502.

[15] Etemad, M.R., Turner, C.E., 1985. An experimental investigation of slow stable crack growth using HY130 steel. Journal of Strain Analysis for Engineering Design, 20(4):201-208.

[16] Etemad, M.R., John, S.J., Turner, C.E., 1988. Elastic-Plastic R-Curves for Large Amounts of Crack Growth. The 18th Symposium on Fracture Mechanics, ASTM STP 945, p.986-1004.

[17] Garwood, S.J., Robinson, J.N., Turner, C.E., 1975. The measurement of crack growth resistance curves (R-curves) using the J integral. International Journal of Fracture, 11(3):528-530.

[18] Hancock, J.W., Reuter, W.G., Parks, D.M., 1993. Constraint and Toughness Parameterized by T. Constraint Effects in Fracture, ASTM STP 1171, p.21-40.

[19] Herrera, R., Landes, J.D., 1988. Direct J-R curve analysis of fracture toughness test. Journal of Testing and Evaluation, 16(5):427-449.

[20] Herrera, R., Landes, J.D., 1990. Direct J-R Curve Analysis: A Guide to the Methodology. The 21st Symposium on Fracture Mechanics, ASTM STP 1074, p.24-43.

[21] Hu, J.M., Albrecht, P., Joyce, J.A., 1992. Load Ratio Method for Estimating Crack Extension. The 22nd Symposium on Fracture Mechanics, ASTM STP 1131(I), p.880-903.

[22] Hutchinson, J.W., 1968. Singular behavior at the end of a tensile crack in a hardening material. Journal of the Mechanics and Physics of Solids, 16(1):13-31.

[23] Hutchinson, J.W., Paris, P.C., 1979. Stability Analysis of J-Controlled Crack Growth. Elastic-Plastic Fracture, ASTM STP 668, p.37-64.

[24] Johnson, H.H., 1965. Calibrating the electric potential method for studying slow crack growth. Materials Research and Standards, 5(9):442-445.

[25] Joyce, J.A., 1992. J-Resistance Curve Testing of Short Crack Bend Specimens Using Unloading Compliance. The 22nd Symposium on Fracture Mechanics, ASTM STP 1131(I), p.904-924.

[26] Joyce, J.A., 1996. Manual on Elastic-Plastic Fracture: Laboratory Test Procedures. ASTM Manual Series, MNL27, West Conshohocken, PA, USA.

[27] Joyce, J.A., 2001. Analysis of a high rate round robin based on proposed annexes to ASTM E 1820. Journal of Testing and Evaluation, 29(4):329-351.

[28] Joyce, J.A., Gudas, J.P., 1979. Computer Interactive JIC Testing of Navy Alloys. Elastic-Plastic Fracture, ASTM STP 668, p.451-468.

[29] Joyce, J.A., Link, R.E., 1995. Effects of Constraint on Upper Shelf Fracture Toughness. The 26th Symposium on Fatigue and Fracture Mechanics, ASTM STP 1265, p.142-177.

[30] Joyce, J.A., Link, R.E., 1997. Application of two parameter elastic-plastic fracture mechanics to analysis of structures. Engineering Fracture Mechanics, 57(4):431-446.

[31] Joyce, J.A., Joyce, P.J., 2004. Toughness characterization of a metal filled polytetrafluoro-ethylene using the J-integral. Engineering Fracture Mechanics, 71(16-17):2513-2531.

[32] Joyce, J.A., Ernst, H., Paris, P.C., 1980. Direct J-R Curve Analysis: A Guide to the Methodology. The 12th National Symposium on Fracture Mechanics, ASTM STP 700, p.222-236.

[33] Joyce, J.A., Hackett, E.M., Roe, C., 1993. Effect of Crack Depth and Mode of Loading on the J-R Curve Behavior of a High-Strength Steel. Constraint Effects in Fracture, ASTM STP 1171, p.239-263.

[34] Joyce, J.A., Albrecht, P., Tjiang, H.C., Wright, W.J., 2001. Compliance Ratio Method of Estimating Crack Length in Dynamic Fracture Toughness Tests. Fatigue and Fracture Mechanics, ASTM STP 1406, p.139-157.

[35] Kanninen, M.F., Popelar, C.H., 1985. Advanced Fracture Mechanics. Oxford University Press, New York.

[36] Kim, Y.J., Schwalbe, K.H., 2001. On experimental J estimation equations based on CMOD for SE(B) specimen. Journal of Testing and Evaluation, 29(1):67-71.

[37] Kim, Y.J., Kim, J.S., Cho, S.M., Kim, Y.J., 2004. 3-D constraint effects on J testing and crack tip constraint in M(T), SE(B), SE(T), C(T) specimens: numerical study. Engineering Fracture Mechanics, 71(9-10):1203-1218.

[38] Kirk, M.T., Dodds, R.H., 1993. J and CTOD estimation equations for shallow cracks in single edge notch bend specimens. Journal of Testing and Evaluation, 21(4):228-238.

[39] Kroon, M., Faleskog, J., Oberg, H., 2008. A probabilistic model for cleavage fracture with a length scale— parameter estimation and predictions of growing crack experiments. Engineering Fracture Mechanics, 75(8):2398-2417.

[40] Lam, P.S., Chao, Y.J., Zhu, X.K., Kim, Y., Sindelar, R.L., 2003. Determination of constraint-modified J-R curves for carbon steel storage tanks. Journal of Pressure Vessel Technology, 125(2):136-143.

[41] Landes, J.D., Begley, J.A., 1972. The Effect of Specimen Geometry on JIC. Fracture Mechanics, ASTM STP 515, p.24-39.

[42] Landes, J.D., Walker, H., Clarke, G.A., 1979. Evaluation of Estimation Procedures Used in J-Integral Testing. Elastic-Plastic Fracture, ASTM STP 668, p.266-287.

[43] Landes, J.D., Zhou, Z., Lee, K., Herrera, R., 1991. Normalization method for developing J-R curves with the LMN function. Journal of Testing and Evaluation, 19(4):305-311.

[44] Leis, B.N., Zhu, X.K., Shen, G., Tyson, W.R., 2009. Effective Experimental Measurement and Constraint Quantification of J-R Curves for X80 Pipeline Steel. Proceedings of the 12th International Conference on Fracture, Ottawa, Canada.

[45] Marschall, C.W., Held, P.R., Landow, M.P., Mincer, P.N., 1990. Use of the Direct-Current Electric Potential Method to Monitor Large Amounts of Crack Growth in Highly Ductile Metals. The 21st Symposium on Fracture Mechanics, ASTM STP 1074, p.581-593.

[46] Merkle, J.G., Corten, H.T., 1974. A J integral analysis for the compact specimen, considering axial force as well as bending effects. Journal of Pressure Vessel Technology, 96(4):286-292.

[47] Milne, I., Ritchie, R.O., Karihaloo, B., 2003. Comprehensive Structural Integrity. Elsevier Science, Amsterdam, Holand.

[48] Morhain, C., Velasco, J.I., 2002. J-R curve determination of magnesium hydroxide filled polypropylene using the normalization method. Journal of Materials Science, 37(8):1635-1644.

[49] Morrison, J., Karisallen, K.J., 1995. An experimental comparison of J and CTOD estimation formulas. Engineering Fracture Mechanics, 51(1):145-149.

[50] Neimitz, A., 2008. The jump-like crack growth model, the estimation of fracture energy and JR curve. Engineering Fracture Mechanics, 75(2):236-252.

[51] Neimitz, A., Dzioba, I., Galkiewicz, J., Molasy, R., 2004. A study of stable crack growth using experimental methods, finite elements and fractography. Engineering Fracture Mechanics, 71(9-10):1325-1355.

[52] Nevalainen, M., Dodds, R.H., 1990. Numerical investigation of 3-D constraint effects on brittle fracture in SE(B) and C(T) specimens. International Journal of Fracture, 74(2):131-161.

[53] Newman, J.C., James, M.A., Zerbst, U., 2003. A review of the CTOA/STOD fracture criterion. International Journal of Fracture, 70(3-4):371-385.

[54] O′Dowd, N.P., Shih, C.F., 1991. Family of crack-tip fields characterized by a triaxiality parameter—I. Structure of fields. Journal of the Mechanics and Physics of Solids, 39(8):989-1015.

[55] O′Dowd, N.P., Shih, C.F., 1994. Two-parameter Fracture Mechanics: Theory and Applications. Fracture Mechanics, ASTM STP 1207, p.21-47.

[56] Oh, Y.J., Hwang, I.S., 2006. Review of dynamic loading J-R curve method for leak before break of nuclear piping. Nuclear Engineering and Technology, 38(7):639-656.

[57] Oh, Y.J., Hwang, I.S., Joyce, J.A., 2006. Round robin test on normalization method under static loading condition. Journal of Testing and Evaluation, 34(6):537-561.

[58] Orange, T.W., 1990. Methods and Models for R-Curve Instability Calculations. The 21st Symposium on Fracture Mechanics, ASTM STP 1074, p.545-559.

[59] Paris, P.C., Ernst, H., Turner, C.E., 1980. A J-Integral Approach to the Development of η Factors. The 12th Conference on Fracture Mechanics, ASTM STP 700, p.338-251.

[60] Reynolds, A.P., 1996. Comparison of R-curve methodologies for ranking the toughness of aluminum alloys. Journal of Testing and Evaluation, 24(6):406-410.

[61] Rice, J.R., 1968. A path independent integral and the approximate analysis of strain concentration by notches and cracks. Journal of Applied Mechanics, 35(2):379-386.

[62] Rice, J.R., Rosengren, G.F., 1968. Plane strain deformation near a crack tip in a power law hardening material. Journal of the Mechanics and Physics of Solids, 16(1):1-12.

[63] Rice, J.R., Paris, P.C., Merkle, J.G., 1973. Some Further Results of J-Integral Analysis and Estimates. Progress in Flaw Growth and Fracture Toughness Testing, ASTM STP 536, p.231-245.

[64] Schwalbe, K.H., Hellmann, D., 1981. Application of the electrical potential method to crack length measurements using Johnson’s formula. Journal of Testing and Evaluation, 9(3):218-221.

[65] Schwalbe, K.H., Setz, W., 1981. R curve and fracture toughness of thin sheet materials. Journal of Testing and Evaluation, 9(4):182-194.

[66] Scibetta, M., Lucon, E., Schuurmans, J., van Walle, E., 2006. Numerical simulations to support the normalization data reduction technique. Engineering Fracture Mechanics, 73(4):524-534.

[67] Sharobeam, M.H., Landes, J.D., 1991. The load separation criterion and methodology in ductile fracture mechanics. International Journal of Fracture, 47(2):81-104.

[68] Sharobeam, M.H., Landes, J.D., 1993. The load separation and ηpl development in precracked specimen test records. International Journal of Fracture, 59(3):213-226.

[69] Shen, G., Tyson, W.R., Glover, A., Horsley, D., 2004. Constraint Effects on Linepipe Toughness. Proceedings of the 4th International Conference on Pipeline Technology, Ostend, Belgium, 2:703-720.

[70] Sumpter, J.D.G., 1987. JC determination for shallow notch welded bend specimens. Fatigue and Fracture of Engineering Materials and Structures, 10(6):479-493.

[71] Sumpter, J.D.G., Turner, C.E., 1976. Method for Laboratory Determination of JC (Contour Integral for Fracture Analysis). Cracks and Fracture, ASTM STP 601, p.3-18.

[72] Tada, H., Paris, P.C., Irwin, G.R., 1973. The Stress Analysis of Cracks Handbook. Del Research Corporation, Hellertown, PA, USA.

[73] Turner, C.E., 1973. Fracture toughness and specific energy: a reanalysis of results. Materials Science and Engineering, 11(5):275-282.

[74] Turner, C.E., 1981. Fracture mechanics assessment and design. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A: Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences, 299(1446):73-92.

[75] Turner, C.E., 1983. Further Development of J-Based Design Curve and Its Relationship to Other Procedures. Elastic-Plastic Fracture, ASTM STP 803(II), p.80-102.

[76] Wallin, K., Laukkanen, A., 2004. Improved crack growth corrections for J-R curve testing. Engineering Fracture Mechanics, 71(11):1601-1614.

[77] Wang, Y.Y., Reemsnyder, H.S., Kirk, M.T., 1997. Inference Equations for Fracture Toughness Testing: Numerical Analysis and Experimental Verification. Fatigue and Fracture Mechanics, ASTM STP 1321, p.469-484.

[78] Wu, S.X., Mai, Y.W., Cotterell, B., 1988. Plastic rotation factors of three-point bend and compact tension specimens. Journal of Testing and Evaluation, 16(6):555-557.

[79] Wu, S.X., Mai, Y.W., Cotterell, B., 1990. Plastic η-factor of fracture specimens with deep and shallow cracks. International Journal of Fracture, 45(1):1-18.

[80] Yang, S., Chao, Y.J., Sutton, M.A., 1993. Higher-order asymptotic fields in a power-law hardening material. Engineering Fracture Mechanics, 45(1):1-20.

[81] Zerbst, U., Heinimann, M., Donne, C.D., Steglich, D., 2009. Fracture and damage mechanics modeling of thin-walled structures—an overview. Engineering Fracture Mechanics, 76(1):5-43.

[82] Zhou, D.W., Xu, W.G., Smith, S.D., 2009. R-curve Modeling with Constraint Effect. Proceedings of the 12th International Conference on Fracture, Ottawa, Canada.

[83] Zhu, X.K., Chao, Y.J., 2001. Constraint effects on crack-tip fields in elastic-perfectly plastic materials. Journal of the Mechanics and Physics of Solids, 49(2):363-399.

[84] Zhu, X.K., Jang, S.K., 2000. J-R curves corrected by load independent parameter in ductile crack growth. Engineering Fracture Mechanics, 68(3):285-301.

[85] Zhu, X.K., Chao, Y.J., 2005. Specimen size requirements for two parameter fracture toughness testing. International Journal of Fracture, 135(1-4):117-136.

[86] Zhu, X.K., Leis, B.N., 2006a. Application of constraint-corrected J-R curve to fracture analysis of pipelines. Journal of Pressure Vessel Technology, 128(4):581-589.

[87] Zhu, X.K., Leis, B.N., 2006b. Bending modified J-Q theory and crack-tip constraint quantification. International Journal of Fracture, 141(1-2):115-134.

[88] Zhu, X.K., Leis, B.N., 2006c. Constraint corrected J-R curve and its applications for X80 pipeline. Journal of ASTM International, 3(6), paper ID JAI13209.

[89] Zhu, X.K., Joyce, J.A., 2007. J-resistance curve testing of HY80 steel using SE(B) specimens and normalization method. Engineering Fracture Mechanics, 74(14):2263-2281.

[90] Zhu, X.K., Leis, B.N., 2008a. Fracture resistance curve testing of X80 pipeline steel using SENB specimen and normalization method. Journal of Pipeline Engineering, 7(2):126-136.

[91] Zhu, X.K., Leis, B.N., 2008b. Experimental Determination of J-R Curves Using SENB Specimen and P-CMOD Data. Proceedings of ASME Pressure Vessel and Piping Conference, Chicago, Illinois, USA.

[92] Zhu, X.K., Joyce, J.A., 2009a. More Accurate Approximation of J-integral Equation for Evaluating Fracture Resistance Curves. The 9th International ASTM/ESIS Symposium on Fatigue and Fracture Mechanics, Vancouver, Canada.

[93] Zhu, X.K., Joyce, J.A., 2009b. Revised incremental J-integral equations for ASTM E1820 using crack mouth opening displacement. Journal of Testing and Evaluation, 37(3):205-214.

[94] Zhu, X.K., Jang, S.K., Chen, Y.F., 2001. A modification of J-Q theory and its applications. International Journal of Fracture, 111(3):L47-L52.

[95] Zhu, X.K., Leis, B.N., Joyce, J.A., 2008. Experimental evaluation of J-R curves from load-CMOD record for SE(B) specimens. Journal of Pressure Vessels and Piping, 5(5), paper ID JAI101532.

[96] Zhu, X.K., Lam, P.S., Chao, Y.J., 2009. Applications of normalization method to experimental measurement of fracture toughness for A285 carbon steel. Journal of Pressure Vessels and Piping, 86(10):669-676.

Open peer comments: Debate/Discuss/Question/Opinion


Erik Knudsen@Naval Research Laboratory<erik.knudsen.ctr@nrl.navy.mil>

2011-11-03 08:59:56

I think it is very interesting! I think this is a very nice review of the J-testing methods over the years.


2010-01-29 10:35:43

The invited Review presents an survey of the state of the art of the J-integral resistance curve. Both test methods and experimental evaluations are addressed with interesting discussions on particular aspects. Welcome you comments!

Please provide your name, email address and a comment

Journal of Zhejiang University-SCIENCE, 38 Zheda Road, Hangzhou 310027, China
Tel: +86-571-87952783; E-mail: cjzhang@zju.edu.cn
Copyright © 2000 - Journal of Zhejiang University-SCIENCE