Abstract: In the context of global decarbonization initiatives and the rapid advancement of electrified railways, the efficient utilization of regenerative braking energy (RBE) has emerged as a critical energy policy in China. RBE not only significantly reduces railway energy consumption but also offers substantial potential for providing auxiliary services to the power grid, enhancing the coordination, economic efficiency, and stability of both railway and power systems. In this paper, we first analyze RBE utilization strategies, including the optimization of train operation scheduling, energy storage technologies, energy sharing mechanisms, and energy feedback configurations. Then, from a macro perspective, the hierarchical structure of the RBE control system is explored. The upper-level energy management system of regenerative braking exhibits development trends based mainly on thresholds, optimization, and learning. Meanwhile, the lower-level converter control system tends to adopt strategies that improve the voltage balance and circulating current performance of the modular multilevel converter-railway power conditioner (MMC-RPC) while reducing the computational burden. Finally, based on existing theoretical research and practical engineering applications, rational suggestions are proposed to enhance the utilization efficiency of RBE. These recommendations provide strong support for the efficient utilization of RBE in alternating-current electrified railways (ACERs), as well as for technological innovation and economic development.

交流电气化铁路再生制动能量综合利用研究综述

[1]AbadG,2016.Power Electronics and Electric Drives for Traction Applications.John Wiley & Sons,Inc.,Chichester, UK.

[2]AliMH,WuB,DougalRA,2010.An overview of SMES applications in power and energy systems.IEEE Transactions on Sustainable Energy,1(1):38-47.

[3]BahraniB,DebnathS,SaeedifardM,2016.Circulating current suppression of the modular multilevel converter in a double-frequency rotating reference frame.IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics,31(1):783-792.

[4]BeerS,GomezT,DallingerD,et al.,2012.An economic analysis of used electric vehicle batteries integrated into commercial building microgrids.IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid,3(1):517-525.

[5]BerruetaA,UrsúaA,MartínIS,et al.,2019.Supercapacitors: electrical characteristics, modeling, applications, and future trends.IEEE Access,7:50869-50896.

[6]BilbaoE,BarradeP,Etxeberria-OtaduiI,et al.,2014.Optimal energy management strategy of an improved elevator with energy storage capacity based on dynamic programming.IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications,50(2):1233-1244.

[7]BoevP,ZimmermannU,EbrechtB,et al.,2023.First passenger operation of a state-of-the-art battery-electric multiple unit (BEMU) in Germany.Transportation Research Procedia,72:2510-2517.

[8]BrennaM,FoiadelliF,ZaninelliD,2010.Electromagnetic model of high speed railway lines for power quality studies.IEEE Transactions on Power Systems,25(3):1301-1308.

[9]BrennaM,FoiadelliF,KaleybarHJ,et al.,2019.Smart electric railway substation using local energy hub based multi-port railway power flow controller.Proceedings of the IEEE Vehicle Power and Propulsion Conference (VPPC), p.1-6.

[10]ChenBC,ZhangCM,TianCH,et al.,2016.A hybrid electrical magnetic power quality compensation system with minimum active compensation capacity for V/V cophase railway power supply system.IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics,31(6):4159-4170.

[11]ChenJY,HuHT,GeYB,et al.,2022.Techno-economic model-based capacity design approach for railway power conditioner-based energy storage system.IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics,69(5):4730-4741.

[12]ChenJY,HuHT,WangMH,et al.,2024a.Power flow control-based regenerative braking energy utilization in AC electrified railways: review and future trends.IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems,25(7):6345-6365.

[13]ChenJY,ZhaoY,WangMH,et al.,2024b.Power sharing and storage-based regenerative braking energy utilization for sectioning post in electrified railways.IEEE Transactions on Transportation Electrification,10(2):2677-2688.

[14]ChenMW,ChengYL,ChengZ,et al.,2020.Energy storage traction power supply system and control strategy for an electrified railway.IET Generation, Transmission & Distribution,14(12):2304-2314.

[15]ChenTM,JinY,LvHY,et al.,2020.Applications of lithium-ion batteries in grid-scale energy storage systems.Transactions of Tianjin University,26(3):208-217.

[16]CiccarelliF,IannuzziD,2012.A novel energy management control of wayside Li-ion capacitors-based energy storage for urban mass transit systems.Proceedings of the International Symposium on Power Electronics Power Electronics, Electrical Drives, Automation and Motion, p.773-779.

[17]CiccarelliF,IannuzziD,TricoliP,2012.Control of metro-trains equipped with onboard supercapacitors for energy saving and reduction of power peak demand.Transportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies,24:36-49.

[18]CiccarelliF,Del PizzoA,IannuzziD,2014.Improvement of energy efficiency in light railway vehicles based on power management control of wayside lithium-ion capacitor storage.IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics,29(1):275-286.

[19]DaiNY,LaoKW,WongMC,et al.,2012.Hybrid power quality conditioner for co-phase power supply system in electrified railway.IET Power Electronics,5(7):1084-1094.

[20]DingD,WuXY,2024.Hydrogen fuel cell electric trains: technologies, current status, and future.Applications in Energy and Combustion Science,17:100255.

[21]FedeleE,IannuzziD,Del PizzoA,2021.Onboard energy storage in rail transport: review of real applications and techno-economic assessments.IET Electrical Systems in Transportation,11(4):279-309.

[22]FengC,GaoZX,SunYY,et al.,2021.Electric railway smart microgrid system with integration of multiple energy systems and power-quality improvement.Electric Power Systems Research,199:107459.

[23]FilogranoML,Corredera GuillenP,Rodriguez-BarriosA,et al.,2012.Real-time monitoring of railway traffic using fiber Bragg grating sensors.IEEE Sensors Journal,12(1):85-92.

[24]GraberG,CalderaroV,GaldiV,et al.,2022.Impact assessment of energy storage systems supporting DC railways on AC power grids.IEEE Access,10:10783-10798.

[25]HanZQ,LiuSP,WeiX,et al.,2013.Study on protection scheme for cophase supply equipment.Journal of the China Railway Society,35(2):21-25(in Chinese).

[26]HayashiyaH,YokokawaS,IinoY,et al.,2016.Regenerative energy utilization in a.c. traction power supply system.Proceedings of the IEEE International Power Electronics and Motion Control Conference (IPEMC), p.1125-1130.

[27]HeLZ,2013.High-performance bridge modular switched-capacitor converter with small component requirement based on output impedance analysis for low loss.IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics,28(10):4668-4680.

[28]HeXQ,PengJC,HanP,et al.,2019.A novel advanced traction power supply system based on modular multilevel converter.IEEE Access,7:165018-165028.

[29]HuXS,DengXC,WangF,et al.,2022.A review of second-life lithium-ion batteries for stationary energy storage applications.Proceedings of the IEEE,110(6):735-753.

[30]IannuzziD,LauriaD,TricoliP,2012.Optimal design of stationary supercapacitors storage devices for light electrical transportation systems.Optimization and Engineering,13(4):689-704.

[31]KhodaparastanM,MohamedAA,BrandauerW,2019.Recuperation of regenerative braking energy in electric rail transit systems.IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems,20(8):2831-2847.

[32]KonishiT,YoshiiT,ShigeedaH,2014.Improvement of control method for fixed energy storage system.Quarterly Report of RTRI,55(2):79-85.

[33]LeeH,SongJ,LeeH,et al.,2011.Capacity optimization of the supercapacitor energy storages on DC railway system using a railway powerflow algorithm.International Journal of Innovative Computing, Information and Control,7(5B):2739-2753.

[34]LeeS,ChoiDH,2019.Reinforcement learning-based energy management of smart home with rooftop solar photovoltaic system, energy storage system, and home appliances.Sensors,19(18):3937.

[35]LiH,PengJ,LiuWR,et al.,2015.Stationary charging station design for sustainable urban rail systems: a case study at Zhuzhou Electric Locomotive Co., China.Sustainability,7(1):465-481.

[36]LiPK,WangY,LiuY,et al.,2023.Impedance modeling and mechanism analysis of low-frequency oscillations in single-phase MMC-RPC integrated vehicle-grid coupling system.IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics,38(4):4820-4839.

[37]LiSH,WangXL,YaoZQ,et al.,2015.Circulating current suppressing strategy for MMC-HVDC based on nonideal proportional resonant controllers under unbalanced grid conditions.IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics,30(1):387-397.

[38]LiangHQ,DongLW,HuJT,et al.,2019.Energy management strategy based on dynamic threshold for energy recovery system in rail transit.Proceedings of the IEEE Vehicle Power and Propulsion Conference (VPPC), p.1-6.

[39]LinBD,2021.Energy management strategy for super capacitor energy storage system based on phase shifted full bridge converter.International Journal of Low-Carbon Technologies,16(3):1077-1086.

[40]LinS,HuangD,WangAM,et al.,2019.Research on the regeneration braking energy feedback system of urban rail transit.IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology,68(8):7329-7339.

[41]LiuRM,LiSK,YangLX,et al.,2020.Energy-efficient subway train scheduling design with time-dependent demand based on an approximate dynamic programming approach.IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics: Systems,50(7):2475-2490.

[42]LiuX,LiK,2020.Energy storage devices in electrified railway systems: a review.Transportation Safety and Environment,2(3):183-201.

[43]LiuY,HanXF,XingZX,et al.,2024.Research on control strategy of hybrid superconducting energy storage based on reinforcement learning algorithm.IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity,34(8):5701404.

[44]LiuYY,YangZP,WuXB,et al.,2021.Adaptive threshold adjustment strategy based on fuzzy logic control for ground energy storage system in urban rail transit.IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology,70(10):9945-9956.

[45]LuQW,GaoZX,HeBB,et al.,2020.Centralized-decentralized control for regenerative braking energy utilization and power quality improvement in modified AC-fed railways.Energies,13(10):2582.

[46]LyuC,HuangZW,LiH,et al.,2019.Distributed control for state-of-energy balancing of supercapacitor modules in light rail vehicles.IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology,68(5):4447-4457.

[47]MaFJ,LuoA,XuXY,et al.,2013.A simplified power conditioner based on half-bridge converter for high-speed railway system.IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics,60(2):728-738.

[48]MaFJ,XuQM,HeZX,et al.,2016.A railway traction power conditioner using modular multilevel converter and its control strategy for high-speed railway system.IEEE Transactions on Transportation Electrification,2(1):96-109.

[49]MaFJ,WangX,DengLF,et al.,2020.Multiport railway power conditioner and its management control strategy with renewable energy access.IEEE Journal of Emerging and Selected Topics in Power Electronics,8(2):1405-1418.

[50]MaQ,MaXP,LuoP,et al.,2023.Research on coordinated control strategy of energy storage type railway power conditioner.IEEE Transactions on Transportation Electrification,9(1):182-195.

[51]MizobuchiT,KondoK,DairakuY,et al.,2022.Energy-management method to reduce the capacity of lithium-ion batteries in hybrid-voltage-source three-level inverter for DC-electrified railway vehicles.IEEE Open Journal of Industry Applications,3:41-55.

[52]MorimotoH,AndoM,MochinagaY,et al.,2002.Development of railway static power conditioner used at substation for Shinkansen.Proceedings of the Power Conversion Conference, p.1108-1111.

[53]MoskowitzJP,CohuauJL,2010.STEEM: ALSTOM and RATP experience of supercapacitors in tramway operation.Proceedings of the IEEE Vehicle Power and Propulsion Conference, p.1-5.

[54]MOT (Ministry of Transport of the People’s Republic of China),2024.The First Domestic Case! Crossing the Qiongzhou Strait by Train in Summer, Bidding Farewell to the Stuffiness, Zhanjiang Maritime Security, Large-Scale ‘Power Bank’, Safe and Uninterrupted Power Supply (in Chinese).https://www.mot.gov.cn/jiaotongyaowen/202407/t20240717_4144711.html

[55]Mousavi GazafrudiSM,Tabakhpour LangerudyA,FuchsEF,et al.,2015.Power quality issues in railway electrification: a comprehensive perspective.IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics,62(5):3081-3090.

[56]Murray-SmithD,2019.A Review of Developments in Electrical Battery, Fuel Cell and Energy Recovery Systems for Railway Applications: a Report for the Scottish Association for Public Transport.Technical Report, Scottish Association for Public Transport, Glasgow,UK.

[57]OgasaM,2008.Energy saving and environmental measures in railway technologies: example with hybrid electric railway vehicles.IEEJ Transactions on Electrical and Electronic Engineering,3(1):15-20.

[58]OgasaM,2010.Onboard storage in Japanese electrified lines.Proceedings of the 14th International Power Electronics and Motion Control Conference EPE-PEMC, p.S7-9-S7-16.

[59]PanZQ,ChenMW,LuSF,et al.,2020.Integrated timetable optimization for minimum total energy consumption of an AC railway system.IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology,69(4):3641-3653.

[60]PrägerP,BisselingA,SchreweRS,et al.,2022.Comparison of a modular multilevel converter–virtual synchronous machine to a synchronous generator of the same power class in different grid scenarios.Proceedings of the IEEE 7th International Energy Conference (ENERGYCON), p.1-5.

[61]QingH,ZhangCJ,ChaiXH,et al.,2023.Research on grid-connected harmonic current suppression of three-phase four-wire energy storage inverters.Journal of Power Electronics,23(6):972-983.

[62]RanaMM,UddinM,SarkarMR,et al.,2023.Applications of energy storage systems in power grids with and without renewable energy integration—a comprehensive review.Journal of Energy Storage,68:107811.

[63]ReniersJM,MulderG,Ober-BlöbaumS,et al.,2018.Improving optimal control of grid-connected lithium-ion batteries through more accurate battery and degradation modelling.Journal of Power Sources,379:91-102.

[64]ReynaudJF,GarmendiaM,NievaT,2018.Comprehensive integration of onboard energy storage systems in tramways: Birmingham tram case study.Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Electrical Systems for Aircraft,Railway,Ship Propulsion and Road Vehicles & International Transportation Electrification Conference (ESARS-ITEC), p.1-6.

[65]RonankiD,WilliamsonSS,2018.Modular multilevel converters for transportation electrification: challenges and opportunities.IEEE Transactions on Transportation Electrification,4(2):399-407.

[66]SadiqD,MansorM,YingYJ,et al.,2021.Review of energy storage systems in regenerative braking energy recovery in DC electrified urban railway systems: converter topologies, control methods & future prospects. TechRxiv.

[67]SaeedM,BrizF,GuerreroJM,et al.,2023.Onboard energy storage systems for railway: present and trends.IEEE Open Journal of Industry Applications,4:238-259.

[68]SahooS,TimmannP,2023.Energy storage technologies for modern power systems: a detailed analysis of functionalities, potentials, and impacts.IEEE Access,11:49689-49729.

[69]SandeepSD,MohantyS,2023.Artificial rabbits optimized neural network-based energy management system for PV, battery, and supercapacitor based isolated DC microgrid system.IEEE Access,11:142411-142432.

[70]ShangYW,WuWC,GuoJB,et al.,2020.Stochastic dispatch of energy storage in microgrids: an augmented reinforcement learning approach.Applied Energy,261:114423.

[71]ShenGQ,ZhuXC,ZhangJ,et al.,2010.A new feedback method for PR current control of LCL-filter-based grid-connected inverter.IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics,57(6):2033-2041.

[72]ShenJY,KhalighA,2015.A supervisory energy management control strategy in a battery/ultracapacitor hybrid energy storage system.IEEE Transactions on Transportation Electrification,1(3):223-231.

[73]ShenXJ,WeiHY,LieTT,2021.Management and utilization of urban rail transit regenerative braking energy based on the bypass DC loop.IEEE Transactions on Transportation Electrification,7(3):1699-1711.

[74]ShuZL,XieSF,LiQZ,2011.Single-phase back-to-back converter for active power balancing, reactive power compensation, and harmonic filtering in traction power system.IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics,26(2):334-343.

[75]ShuaiH,LiFX,Pulgar-PainemalH,et al.,2021.Branching dueling Q-network-based online scheduling of a microgrid with distributed energy storage systems.IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid,12(6):5479-5482.

[76]SongZY,FengS,ZhangL,et al.,2019.Economy analysis of second-life battery in wind power systems considering battery degradation in dynamic processes: real case scenarios.Applied Energy,251:113411.

[77]SunC,SunFC,MouraSJ,2016.Nonlinear predictive energy management of residential buildings with photovoltaics & batteries.Journal of Power Sources,325:723-731.

[78]SunXB,YaoZM,DongCJ,et al.,2023.Optimal control strategies for metro trains to use the regenerative braking energy: a speed profile adjustment approach.IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems,24(6):5883-5894.

[79]SunYX,LiZ,ZhangZB,2019.Hybrid predictive control with simple linear control based circulating current suppression for modular multilevel converters.CES Transactions on Electrical Machines and Systems,3(4):335-341.

[80]SwansonJ,SmatlakJ,2015.State of the art in light rail alternative power supplies.Proceedings of the 13th National Light Rail and Streetcar Conference, p.47-64.

[81]TakarliR,AminiA,KhajueezadehM,et al.,2023.A comprehensive review on flywheel energy storage systems: survey on electrical machines, power electronics converters, and control systems.IEEE Access,11:81224-81255.

[82]TalookiMF,RezanejadM,KhosraviR,et al.,2021.A novel high step-up switched-capacitor multilevel inverter with self-voltage balancing.IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics,36(4):4352-4359.

[83]ThorneR,AmundsenAH,SundvorI,2019.Battery Electric and Fuel Cell Trains: Maturity of Technology and Market Status.Institute of Transport Economics (TØI), Oslo, Norway.

[84]UzukaT,IkedoS,UedaK,et al.,2005.Voltage fluctuation compensator for Shinkansen.IEEJ Transactions on Power and Energy,125(9):885-892.

[85]WangH,LiuY,YanK,et al.,2015.Analysis of static VAr compensators installed in different positions in electric railways.IET Electrical Systems in Transportation,5(3):129-134.

[86]WangJY,WangP,2018.Power decoupling control for modular multilevel converter.IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics,33(11):9296-9309.

[87]WangX,LuoYB,QinB,et al.,2023.Power allocation strategy for urban rail HESS based on deep reinforcement learning sequential decision optimization.IEEE Transactions on Transportation Electrification,9(2):2693-2710.

[88]WangX,GuoQ,TuCM,et al.,2024.A novel hybrid advanced cophase power supply equipment with its operation control strategy.IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics,71(11):13910-13920.

[89]WuCP,LuoA,ShenJ,et al.,2012.A negative sequence compensation method based on a two-phase three-wire converter for a high-speed railway traction power supply system.IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics,27(2):706-717.

[90]WuGH,2021.Reliability analysis of power supply technology of electrified railway.Construction & Design for Project, (8):33-35.

[91]WuPH,ChengPT,2018.Control of delta-connected cascaded converter in the railway power conditioner application.Proceedings of the IEEE Energy Conversion Congress and Exposition (ECCE), p.2790-2797.

[92]XinY,YangZP,LinF,et al.,2019.Research on energy management strategy of supercapacitor energy storage system in urban rail transit based on fuzzy logic control.Proceedings of the IEEE Transportation Electrification Conference and Expo,Asia-Pacific (ITEC Asia-Pacific), p.1-6.

[93]XingZY,ZhangZY,GuoJ,et al.,2023.Rail train operation energy-saving optimization based on improved brute-force search.Applied Energy,330:120345.

[94]YamanoiT,UmedaS,NakamuraY,et al.,2006.Field test of hybrid power supply system for DC electric railways.Proceedings of the 7th World Congress on Railway Research:Progressing Together, p.1-10.

[95]YangHM,ShenWD,YuQ,et al.,2020.Coordinated demand response of rail transit load and energy storage system considering driving comfort.CSEE Journal of Power and Energy Systems,6(4):749-759.

[96]YangZH,YangZP,XiaH,et al.,2018.Brake voltage following control of supercapacitor-based energy storage systems in metro considering train operation state.IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics,65(8):6751-6761.

[97]YingYC,LiuQJ,WuML,et al.,2023.Online energy management strategy of the flexible smart traction power supply system.IEEE Transactions on Transportation Electrification,9(1):981-994.

[98]YousafZ,AliS,KhanI,et al.,2023.Optimized energy management considering renewable energy and demand response in smart grids.Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Emerging Trends in Electrical,Control, andTelecommunication Engineering (ETECTE), p.1-7.

[99]YuanJX,PengLW,ZhouH,et al.,2024.Recent research progress and application of energy storage system in electrified railway.Electric Power Systems Research,226:109893.

[100]ZhangBL,WuCX,MengGZ,et al.,2022.Optimal sizing of onboard hybrid energy storage devices considering the long-term train operation.IEEE Access,10:58360-58374.